A black and white David Lynch directed film with a deformed individual and a nightmarish setting. That quick description can sum up both
The Elephant Man or
Eraserhead quite easily.
The Elephant Man, David Lynch's first mainstream film from 1980, still holds many stylistic values from Lynch's 1977 art house debut,
Eraserhead. Below are visual examples of nearly identical themes and mise en scene, and also SPOILERS abound!
Right off the bat, both films have cool double exposures.
But those cool double exposures have deeper meanings behind them concerning creating life, and the fragility of that life. Both films discuss the theme of giving birth to something deformed and
irregular. In
Eraserhead Henry, the main protagonist, has dinner at his girlfriend Mary X's parent's
house. Mrs. X grills Henry about his sexual relationship with Mary and
breaks the news that Mary gave birth to... something.
 |
| "Mother, they don't even know if it is a baby!" |
In this scenario the product of sex is more than the responsibility
of a child, it's an abomination against humanity. It's a punishment and a
shame.
 |
| Beautiful mothers. |
In
The Elephant Man, John Merrick (the Elephant Man) is known to have a
beautiful mother and no known father. The opening shots imply that his
mother was raped by elephants, causing his deformity, but that is
obviously highly improbable, and more of a fantasy origin story. Though
the thought of bestial rape is horrible, it is maybe somehow less
horrible than the hard truth of raping a fellow human being, or
that diseases like
neurofibromatosis exist.
This is a frame from
the beginning of
The Elephant Man, showing Dr. Treves (Anthony Hopkins) walking through the
freak show, and it sums up the film in a matter of a second.
I noticed that the sign here says "The Fruit of the Original
Sin" and it shows only Eve, the tempting snake, and a fetus in a jar.
It's hard to see the fetus, but one can assume that it was deformed by
the mere fact it's featured in a freak show. The symbolism is huge here,
showing only the mother, no father, and the animal this poor soul is
associated with, very much like John Merrick's story. It's obvious that
the "original sin" here is copulation, and the "fruit" is the deformed child.
The two main protagonists of
The Elephant Man are Dr.
Frederick Treves and
John Merrick. The two main characters of
Eraserhead are Henry and
"the baby." It can be argued which characters are the lead or
supporting. Connections between John Merrick and the baby can be bridged by
the superficial idea that they are deformed.
 |
| The baby |
The baby, regardless of
it's deformities, is still a baby, and therefore cannot do much more
than cry and exist. John Merrick is an individual who's initial worth
was only to exist for a freak show, but despite his difficulties communicating, is found to be a man capable of higher thought and
appreciation of the arts.
 |
| John Merrick |
Both individuals have handicaps, and must be looked after. The baby is never moved from it's pillow bed. It is always swaddled, but when Henry decides to cut off the wrapping all Hell breaks loose, and it is clear (well maybe not
clear) that the baby needed the swaddling.
John Merrick must sleep very awkwardly hunched forward with his head between his knees. If he were to sleep flat on his back like a regular person, he would suffocate and die.
He also has a covering; the hood and cloak he wears in public.
In viewing the visual similarities between these films, the use of men's suits struck me as well. Of course John Merrick wore a suit like any other man from his time period. Having him wear a suit was not a stylistic choice of Lynch as much as a necessity to properly tell this true story.
The nightmare scene in Eraserhead, (or is it all a nightmare? - no one can really know, but this was the most surreal part of the film, so let's refer to it as "the nightmare") when the baby's head replaces Henry's, is a visual precursor to the deformed John Merrick wearing the gentleman's suit. This scene in is obviously symbolic of Henry's paternity to the infant, and the horror of this truth. The Elephant Man becomes a functioning member of British high society, because he is a man - not an animal - and he is someones child, despite the horror that may bring some people.
The sets in
The Elephant Man are stylistically similar to
Eraserhead. Lynch made
Eraserhead's setting an industrial fever dream based on his
experience living in Philadelphia. Therefore the sets are filthy, metallic, and treeless.
 |
| Eraserhead |
They are filled with pipes and barrels and valves. The sound of trains,
machines and steam fill the soundtrack. Steam is it's own character in
Eraserhead. In the industrial wasteland
Lynch places his characters, it hangs in the air around buildings, and
hisses out of radiators in homes.
 |
| Mary X's house, Eraserhead |
Grim, industrial, smoking, steamy, with virtually no natural beauty;
nineteenth century life in Europe was the perfect palate for Lynch
following
Eraserhead.
 |
| French circus camp, The Elephant Man |
Grimy windows are a given in this atmosphere. Both films feature a "looking through a dirty window" scene.
 |
| I think Henry is here. |
 |
| Mr. Treves looking for John Merrick. |
Sad studio apartments are also something Henry and John Merrick have in common.
 |
| At least I have that paper church I'm building. |
 |
| At least I have my mound of dirt. |
Unbelievably grim realities aside, it wouldn't be a David Lynch film without a creepy dream sequence.
 |
| A hole from Eraserhead. |
Lynch used rings and holes in
Eraserhead as portals to apparent dream sequences and/or and changes in time.
Twin Peaks also uses the symbol of the ring throughout the series, ultimately as a reference to the opening of
The Black Lodge. In
The Elephant Man, Lynch used the hole/ring symbol again to introduce John Merrick's dream sequence.
Sucking the viewer through the one eye hole in John Merrick's modesty hood, we are drawn into his insecurities, his fears, and general view of life. This shot below from the dream sequence is of men working in a factory.
 |
| This could be an actual
machine and factory process for all I know, but since it's David Lynch, and a dream sequence, I
won't rule out that it's just a completely made up surreal action. |
It reminded me of the "Man in the Planet" (as he is referred to on
IMDB). Shirtless, men of industry. Just replace the steam with sparks.
Throughout Lynch's works gross close-ups can be found in almost any
film project. It is still worth noting that Lynch took that instinct
from his first film,
Eraserhead, and included it in
The Elephant Man.
 |
| The baby's eye in Eraserhead. |
The
elephant mouth is nearly unrecognizable, but it visually calls back to
John Merrick's lumpy disfigurement; a closer match to his ailment than
the external view of the creature he is named after.
 |
| Inside the elephant's mouth in The Elephant Man. |
Both films have concluding scenes with angelic figures presumably taking the protagonist to Heaven.
 |
| "In Heaven everything is fine." |
In
Eraserhead the Lady in the Radiator makes several appearances in
Henry's fantasies, and she once again meets him in a blinding white
light. She embraces him in the white light and resounding humming sounds
after the sequence of his apparent beheading.
After John Merrick lays down for his first and last peaceful slumber,
his mother's face appears in a halo in the stars making this comforting
statement: "Never. Oh, never. Nothing will die. The stream flows, the
wind blows, the cloud fleets, the heart beats. Nothing will die."
When I first watched the
The Elephant Man, I heard that familiar Lynchian roar. It's
when he takes the sound of a woman screaming and slows it down so the
voice deepens and distorts.
The Elephant Man must have been one
of the first instances of this. John Merrick's mother is felled by a
group of elephants and her screams sound like the elephant's roar.
Cut to 1:15 to hear the GIF above.
One of the best examples of this sound effect in Lynch's work is in
episode 14 of
Twin Peaks. When cousin Madeline is attacked by Bob, the
scene toggles back and forth between regular speed and slow-mo. Her
voice is deepened as she screams, sounding like an animal, a roaring
fire, or Bob's own maniacal laugh.
Cut to 2:25 to hear the slow-mo scream.
In
Fire Walk With Me, Laura Palmer has a painting in her room of an angel sitting at a table with children. It looks like an illustration that would be in a child's room.
Laura, having lost her innocence long ago, sees the angel disappear, symbolizing her lost innocence, lost hope, and the idea that the angel is no longer looking after her.
This painting is referenced to several times in
Fire Walk With Me, while a similar framed illustration in John Merrick's room is only seen at the very end of
The Elephant Man.
This illustration of a sleeping child represents the peace and a
normalcy that John wished he had. As mentioned earlier, due to his
condition, John Merrick had to sleep sitting up with his head between
his knees. After being honored at the theater, and having one of the
best nights of his life, John studies this illustration and seems to
decide he wants to sleep that way. John is well aware of the danger.
Going to sleep like a regular peaceful child was just the cap to his
wonderful day in his life, and he did not believe it could get any
better. The act was apparent suicide, and definitely not a naive action.
He sees this illustration soon before his death much like Laura Palmer
sees the angel disappear soon before hers.
Also, Laura Palmer went to Heaven too.
Sweet dreams!